Rethink and Discovery II Offers
New Ways of Looking at Old Problems
Join
the Free Webcast of this PIMA Session
on June 20th
2 PM to 5:45 PM Pacific Daylight Savings Time [GMT
minus 8]
The Center for Paper Business and
Industry Studies (CPBIS), in partnership with the Institute
of Paper Science and Technology (IPST) and working in
concert with other global industry organizations plus
the AF & PA's Agenda 2020 initiative, will host the
second "Rethink and Discovery" program
beginning at 2 PM on June 20th from the Colonial Room
in the Westin St. Francis Hotel in San Francisco. The
program will be simultaneously web-broadcasted for interactive
participation by paper industry professionals worldwide.
This "Thought-Leadership Program" is
designed to share business and technological views that
clarify understandings and help stimulate an industry-wide
change and transformation process. The plan is for three
yearly such programs that will each be led by different
and innovative panels of distinguished academic, business
and industry leaders presenting informative and provocative
views to help stimulate and guide the discovery of needed
industry changes in education, business and technology.
The first "Rethink & Discovery-I" program
("Beyond Today's Papermachine") was
web-broadcast from the Paper Summit 2002, held in March
at the Georgia World Congress Center in Atlanta. Taking
a first look at gaps, needs and barriers in the technology
and business management arenas for the paper industry,
the first program had some 150 conference attendees,
and it attracted interactive participation from 36 other
multi-participant locations around the world, including
real-time questions and views being submitted from Finland,
Brazil, England, Spain, Mexico, and the U.S. to the panelists.
According to Jim McNutt, Executive
Director of CPBIS, "Industry leaders are mindful
of the issues and the need for fundamental change and
transformation of the industry; the problem relates to
the old adage of defining the process to fix the bicycle
while continuing to ride in the race."
Del Raymond, Director, Strategic Energy
Alternatives at Weyerhaeuser will give the keynote address
at the June 20th thought-leadership program entitled, Rethink
and Discovery II -- Superintendent's Roundtable.
Dr. Raymond also has been a pioneer in championing and
developing the forest products vision, Agenda 2020, a
strategic planning document that describes where the
industry will need to be in the year 2020 to be competitive.
He has been involved with the U.S. Department of Energy's
Industries of the Future Program since its inception.
He is currently Chair of the Chief Technology Officers
Committee that guides implementation of this vision for
the forest products industry. His keynote will set the
overall tone for the program and lay out the key linkages
between it and the ongoing Agenda 2020 process.
Rethink and Discovery II will
focus on Division and Mill Level operations management
issues. It will include two panel sessions, one with
the recent past, current, and incoming PIMA Presidents,
and one with Seven Mill Level Management leaders. The "Thought-Leadership
Program", of which Rethink and Discovery
II is a part of, is designed to share business and
technological views that clarify understandings and stimulate
an industry-wide change and transformation process. The
plan is for three yearly such Rethink and Discovery programs
that will each be led by different and innovative panels
of distinguished academic, business and industry leaders
presenting informative and provocative views to help
stimulate and guide the discovery of needed industry
changes in education, business and technology.
Katherine Buckman-Davis, Chairman
of the Board of Buckman Laboratories Group will kick
off the event with an overview of what Rethink and
Discovery is all about and a synopsis of Rethink
and Discovery I. Del Raymond will follow with his
keynote address, and then Jim McNutt (CPBIS) will host
the first panel. His fellow panelists will include PIMA
Presidents (Past, Present, and Incoming) Rick Larrick
(GP); Barre Mitchell (Bowater); and Ray Heuchling (Irving).
Each of the panelists will provide their own observations
of what is and is not working in the industry today.
The second panel will be hosted by
DD Smith (Buckman Laboratories). His fellow panelists
will include Boyd Curtis (Potlatch -- Lewiston), Tiger
Teng (Green Bay Pkg. -- Morrilton), Doug Howard (Boise
Cascade -- Boise), John Martin (Riverwood -- Macon),
Nyle Parchim (Weyerhaeuser -- Campti), Simon Gore (Bear
Island, Retired -- Ashland), and Steve Farmer (IP --
Roanoke Rapids). This panel will provide their observation
on what are the critical issues for this industry at
the mill level and what are the roadblocks and barriers
to success.
The Rethink and Discovery II program
(see the Agenda following) will be from 2 PM to 5:45
PM [Pacific Daylight Savings Time- GMT minus 8], in the
Colonial Room of the Westin St. Francis Hotel. The program
will be simultaneously web-broadcast for interactive
participation by paper industry professionals worldwide,
and it will be recorded for later review and comments.
"Rethink & Discovery
- II - Superintendents' Roundtable"
Process for Simulating "Innovation and Creativity"
PIMA International Management Conference, June 20, 2002
Colonial Room, Westin St. Francis Hotel, 2 - 5:45 PM
The industry must begin
to operate much more innovatively, creatively, effectively
and economically to survive! This program will provide
a set of work sessions focused on Division and Mill Levels
Management issues. The goals will be to identify: 1)
the major gaps, need, barriers to improved mill efficiencies
and financial results; 2) what must be done to improve
mill efficiencies; 3) what criteria are needed to assure
effective management of improved mill efficiencies; 4)
what are the proper roles of capital, human resources,
training, maintenance and so on for enhanced mill operations
efficiencies and financial results?
The overall intent is to use "Innovative/Creative
Economically Grounded Best Practices" to seek enhanced
mill operating efficiencies aimed at improved enterprise
financial performance. This program is the second in
a series of an ongoing thought leadership process aimed
at identifying substantive industry gaps, needs, and
solutions to better enterprise financial performance
over time.
Program Agenda:
2:00 To 2:20 PM -- Introductory Remarks:
Kathy Buckman-Davis of Buckman Laboratories will set
The Stage For The Special Program by outlining The Approach
And Goals -- Including Down Stream Plans For More Rethink & Discovery
Programs plus Introduce Key Players For The Program & Keynote
Speaker and provide an overview of the March 2002 Paper
Summit Rethink & Discovery - I "Beyond Today's
Papermachine" Program
2:20 To 2:40 PM -- Keynote Commentary:
Del Raymond of Weyerhaeuser and a key leader for the
Industry's Agenda 2020 Program efforts will provide focused/to
the point keynote comments to set the overall tone for
this special program and lay out linkages to the ongoing
agenda 2020 program.
2:40 To 3:15 PM -- First Panel Session:
Jim McNutt from the Center for Paper Business and Industry
Studies (CPBIS) will host the first panel session, which
will include the past, current and incoming PIMA Presidents
-- Rick Larrick (GP); Barre Mitchell (Bowater); & Ray
Heuchling (Irving). Each panelist will provide a "From
The Heart -- What Is Working And What Is Not" Address.
3:15 To 3:45 PM -- First Panel & Keynote
Speaker Q&A/Open Forum Facilitated Session
3:45 To 4:15 PM -- Second Panel Session:
DD Smith of Buckman Laboratories will host the second
panel session, which will include seven mill level superintendents
-- Boyd Curtis (Potlatch -- Lewiston); Tiger Teng (Green
Bay Pkg. -- Morrilton); Doug Howard (Boise Cascade --
Boise); John Martin (Riverwood -- Macon); Nyle Parchim
(Weyerhaeuser -- Campti); Simon Gore (Bear Island, Retired
-- Ashland); and Steve Farmer (IP -- Roanoke Rapids.
The panel is to collectively address - "What Are
The Mill Level Critical Issues And Roadblocks/Barriers
To Success" they see and why?
4:15 To 4:45 PM -- Second Panel Facilitated
Push/Pull Discussion Session: This session is intended
to draw out superintendents' viewpoints on pre-conference
submitted questions/issues.
4:45 To 5:15 PM -- Second Panel Q&A/Open
Forum Facilitated Session
5:15 To 5:40 PM --First & Second
Panels Joint Facilitated Q&A/Open Forum Session:
Jim McNutt, DD Smith and Kathy-Buckman Davis will co-host
this program ending session - an interactive audience
exchange on gaps, needs and barriers to optimal mill
financial performance across time.
5:40 To 5:45 PM -- Closing Remarks & Adjourn:
Kathy Buckman-Davis will wrap up the program.
Rethink & Discovery I - "Beyond
Today's Papermachine"
March 6, 2002, Atlanta, GA Proceedings Executive Summary
Background --
The increasing rate of consolidations, mill closures,
and supplier bankruptcies are pointing to a growing
gap in paper industry returns in North America and
are exacerbating a fifteen-year steady decline in investor
confidence. The continuous slide of the forest products
industry from a position of 3% of the S&P 500 to
0.6% has caused Wall Street analysts to loose interest
and incentive for investing large amounts of capital
in a declining industry that has marginal performance.
Industry leaders are mindful of the issues and the
need for fundamental change and transformation of the
industry, the problem relates to the old adage of defining
the process to fix the bicycle while continuing to
ride in the race.
The Center for Paper
Business and Industry Studies (CPBIS), in partnership
with the Institute of Paper Science and Technology
(IPST) and in concert with other global industry organizations
plus the AF & PA's Agenda 2020 initiative, is developing
a unique "Thought-Leadership Program" designed
to share business and technological views that clarify
understandings and stimulate an industry-wide change
and transformation process.
This program is the
first of its kind for any industry, and represents
a series of "live" Internet-based "Rethink
and Discovery" programs that are designed
to engage global business and industry leaders. The
plan is for three yearly sessions that will be led
by a panel of distinguished academic, business and
industry leaders presenting informative and provocative
views to help stimulate and guide the discovery of
needed industry changes in education, business and
technology.
This Thought-Leadership
program's uniqueness not only stems from its panel
of experts but its ability to simultaneously interact
with and engage industry leaders from locations around
the globe using new live Web-casting technologies.
The "Rethink & Discovery - I" program
("Beyond Today's Papermachine")1 was
web-broadcast from the Paper Summit 2002, held in March
at the Georgia World Congress Center in Atlanta. The
program was well attended, with nearly 150 conference
attendees, and it attracted interactive participation
from thirty-six other multi-participant locations around
the world, including real-time questions and views
being submitted from Finland, Brazil, England, Spain,
Mexico, and the U.S. to the panelists.
Program Highlights --
The Rethink & Discovery - I program was
structured around a key note address, two coordinated
panel and audience interaction sessions, and an open
forum "needs / gaps / barriers" capstone
open forum discussion session. The overall program
was designed to focus on understanding the potential
business and technological factors that have influenced
the decline in industry financial performance.
Program Rules of the
Road
- Program Premise = Paper Industry
must modernize/retrofit innovatively, creatively, economically.
-
Program Assumption
= Integrated/focused program will stimulate out of
box thinking;
-
Overall Mission
= Seek innovative ways forward for enhanced industry
returns & value creation;
-
Program Goals =
Stimulate dialog on ways forward;
-
Program Activities
= Facilitated meeting of industry thinkers - brainstorming/discussion
mechanism;
-
Program Outcomes
= Understand that this is a process, not an event
- we need to focus on long term efforts to identify
gaps, needs, barriers and next steps forward.
Key Industry Considerations
- Are These Accurate Characterizations of Our Industry?
-
Primary manufacturing/capital
intensive/fragmented/ technology based/mature/monolithic & slow
to adapt industry sector?
-
Focused on doing
what we do instead of figuring out what we should
be doing in the first place?
-
Key competitive
focuses are on cost competitiveness & process
BMP's - not on firm uniqueness?
-
Knowledge sharing
across firms and poor sharing within firms that together
damage competencies?
-
Highly insular
- internally focused - not customer focused & reactive
instead of proactive?
Keynote Address --
Katherine Buckman-Davis (Chairman of the Board of the
Buckman Laboratories business group), covered a wide
array of key issues, including the following:
-
The North American
Paper Industry is under severe pressure, failing
to meet its cost of capital on average over the past
15 years.
-
Although North
America enjoys the highest per capita consumption
of paper-based products globally, the majority of
new consumers/consumption will be from Asia.
-
Major new capital
investments are in Asia and South America, which
are resulting in the lowest cost production facilities
in the world.
-
Congruently, North
America has begun to suffer from a stagnant domestic
market and diminished export market potentials.
-
Our domestic industry
seems to lack innovative thinking, customer focus,
effective capital assets investments and management
outcomes, and a true sense of the value of human
capital and human capital management.
-
The industry needs
to become people and knowledge oriented as well as
customer focused.
-
We lack effective
new R&D and a sound perspective of what creates
and sustains value.
-
We need to move
from a place of "comfortable inaction" to
one of value creation action based on thoughtful
and necessary risk taking if we are to position ourselves
to implement the needed technological breakthroughs
5 or 10 years from now.
Panel Sessions -- The
two focused Panel Sessions of the program covered a "Business
and Economics Session" (Panel Session 1) and
a "Technology & Innovation Session" (Panel
Session 2):
-
Panel Session 1
- Hosted by Jim McNutt (CPBIS). Panel Members - Mark
Wilde (Deutsche Bank, Alex Brown), Mike Kocurek (North
Carolina State University), Gary Helik (Tradition
Financial Services), and Jim Ferris (IPST).
-
Panel Session 2
- Hosted by Bob Kinstrey (Jacobs Engineering). Panel
Members - David Ashcraft (Temple-Inland, retired,
and North Carolina State University), Dan Cappell
(Asten-Johnson), Bob Harrison (formerly of Beloit
and GL&V), and Bob Eamer (TAPPI Board and Domtar,
retired).
These two Panel Sessions
collectively provided factual background information
describing important interrelationships, a wide array
of key issues, factors, and trends - including:
- The effects of the sagging global
economy and the strong US Dollar on shrinking exports
- Excess manufacturing capacity in
highly competitive but slow growing market - potential
contributors toward pricing volatility
- The loss of technical expertise
- the short and long-term impacts of corrective measures
like downsizing and consolidation
- A continued strategy for short-term
business performance and process optimization
- A growing risk aversion and its
relationship to dwindling investments in research and/or
the commercialization of new processes, technologies,
and products
- The growing inability to attract
students and skilled labor into the industry.
Following the informational
presentations, each panel hosted a simultaneous "open
forum discussion" with conference attendees and
Web-cast participants from around the globe. These
discussions were designed to provide participants with
an opportunity to discuss the panel members' views,
and to define potential gaps, barriers, and areas of
needed change. The following points highlight some
of those discussions:
- Technology - Our 100
year old technology needs risk investments and "patient" funding
necessary to support innovative research. Key considerations
raised were:
- A better ROI model is needed
for measuring the commercialization of new technologies,
processes and products.
- Need to move beyond stock
performance and risk aversion, and begin rewarding
innovators and risk takers.
- "Look-outside-the-box" at
similar industries (i.e. steel industry), and
listen to the technological and business lessons
learned.
- Off-loading of company-concentric
research to outside institutions and companies
that are threatened by financial solvency and
budgetary issues places needed business-enhancing
R&D at substantial risk.
-
Products & Pricing -
We need better information and understanding of price
behavior such as what global market factors most
influence pricing behavior.
-
Industry Structure & Information -
Our accounting systems need to help drive computerized
production and process control systems, fragmentation
of industry associations interferes with effective
communications. Today we see:
-
Employee Talents, Education & Training -
People and knowledge are critical to success. Our
failure of late is to find the needed good people,
secure their attendant knowledge, advance their skills,
and retain both the people and the knowledge in the
industry. In this regard, we need to understand that:
-
Workforce training
investments have been inadequate.
-
We have a growing
need for new talents while image and recruiting
is inadequate.
-
New cooperative
education programs need to be developed -- where,
how and what is taught needs to change - educators,
suppliers, associations and manufacturers need
to cooperate to affect effective, efficient needed
changes in this regard.
-
We need to
understand that there is an ROI for training
and education - equally important how to derive
and work with it.
The panel presentations
and many of the views expressed during the discussions
and the program ending "gaps, needs and barriers" open
forum session together provided useful context for
future Rethink & Discovery sessions. The
full "Rethink & Discovery - I" Program
proceedings can be found on the CPBIS web site at:
http://www.cpbis.gatech.edu/news_events/events/misc/020306_Beyond_Todays_Papermachine_Proceedings.ppt
and IPST web site at
:
http://www.ipst.edu/news_events/misc_events/020306_Beyond_Todays_Papermachine_Proceedings.ppt
1 Paper
Summit "Rethink - I" Session web cast - Beyond
Today's Papermachine -- Sponsored by: Asten-Johnson,
Jacobs, Halliburton KBR, Buckman Laboratories, StoraEnso,
UPM Kymmene, Deutsche Bank, Technical Financial Services,
ForestWeb, PaperLoop.com, U4all.com, NC State University,
IPST, and CPBIS.
|